A Surprising Surge in Fines Under a School Street Scheme
A London council has issued over £1m in penalty charge notices (PCNs) to drivers in just under two years under a School Street initiative. The scheme, introduced outside Manor School in Kensal Rise in November 2024, aims to improve road safety and reduce pollution around schools. However, the sheer volume of fines has raised questions about the program’s effectiveness and its true purpose.
The Numbers Behind the Scheme
Brent Council reported that more than £1.15m in fines were issued during the 21 months the scheme has been active. On average, the council collected £54,799 per month, with the program only in place during term time. In July 2025 alone, two cameras outside the school generated over £107,000 in a single month. These figures highlight the scale of enforcement and the number of drivers being caught violating the road closure rules.
Previously, it was reported that 70,000 PCNs were issued in 12 months, averaging 384 per school day. This suggests that the scheme has been highly active, with a significant number of drivers still attempting to use the road during restricted times.
Concerns About Visibility and Enforcement
Local officials have raised concerns about the visibility of the signs used to enforce the scheme. Ward councillor Barbara Want pointed out that the signs were “too high and not properly visible,” which could contribute to drivers unknowingly breaking the rules. While the council claims the signs comply with Department for Transport guidelines, it has decided to install additional lower-level signs and gateway features to improve clarity for drivers.
Despite these changes, the high number of fines continues to suggest that the scheme may not be achieving its intended goals. Want argued that the £1m in fines over two years indicates a deeper issue, stating that the program may be more focused on revenue generation than on improving safety or air quality.
The Council’s Response
Promise Knight, the council’s cabinet member for cleaner streets, transport, and public realm, emphasized that the School Streets initiative is designed to make the journey to and from school safer for children and families. The program aims to reduce congestion and improve air quality by limiting vehicle access during drop-off and pick-up times.
The council has stated that it will continue to review the scheme and make practical improvements where necessary. This includes evaluating the effectiveness of the signage and enforcement methods to ensure that drivers are better informed and that the program achieves its intended outcomes.
What This Means for Drivers and Communities
For drivers, the high number of fines under the School Street scheme is a clear warning that the rules are being strictly enforced. With penalties of £160 per violation, and a reduced rate of £80 if paid within 14 days, the financial impact can be significant for those who repeatedly break the rules.
For local communities, the scheme has the potential to improve road safety and reduce pollution around schools. However, the high volume of fines raises concerns about whether the program is being used as a tool for revenue generation rather than for the public good. Parents and residents may be left questioning whether the program is truly focused on protecting children or if it is more about collecting fines.
A Call for Balance
As the School Street initiative continues to be tested across the borough, it is clear that a balance must be struck between enforcement and education. While the fines serve as a deterrent, they may not be enough to change driver behavior if the signage and communication are not clear. The success of the program will depend on whether it can effectively reduce traffic and pollution while ensuring that drivers are not unfairly penalized for unclear rules.
{{appel_action}}
Source : BBC News - UK