A New Era in Christmas Advertising
This year, the Christmas ad battle is heating up. For years, John Lewis has dominated the festive advertising scene with its emotional storytelling and grandiose settings. But now, M&S is stepping up with a fresh, playful approach that’s already making waves.
M&S: A Playful and Modern Take
M&S’s 2023 Christmas ad features James Norton as a topless Santa, wrapped in a white cotton towel. The ad is described as “playful and tongue in cheek without being silly” by Gurjit Degun of Campaign magazine. This approach is a far cry from the traditional tearjerker style that John Lewis has long been known for.
The ad brings together M&S’s fashion, food, beauty, and homeware offerings into one cohesive campaign. Norton plays an undercover Santa who shaves off his beard to experience the buildup to Christmas incognito, while Lucy Punch portrays a snobbish Mrs Claus. The ad emphasizes shared moments over big gifts, with every element—from Punch’s pyjamas to the prawn cones—available for purchase.
John Lewis: A Glamorous but Controversial Approach
John Lewis’s ad features Kristin Scott Thomas as a glamorous grandmother who transforms one room of her large house into a “gran cave.” While the ad has been praised for its elegance, it has also faced criticism for being out of touch with the current economic climate. The portrayal of wealth and ungrateful grandchildren has been seen as disconnected from the average consumer’s experience.
The main message from John Lewis’s ad is to give physical gifts rather than cash. This strategy is aimed at affluent customers who have disposable income, according to Jonathan De Mello of JDM Retail consulting. However, this approach may alienate younger consumers who find the lifestyle portrayed in the ad unattainable.
What’s in It for You, the Consumer?
Both ads are not just about storytelling—they’re also about shopping. M&S’s ad highlights the importance of shared moments and the joy of small, everyday experiences. John Lewis’s ad, on the other hand, focuses on the value of physical gifts and the emotional connection they bring.
For consumers, this means more options than ever before. Whether you’re looking for a fun, festive gift or a meaningful present, both M&S and John Lewis have something to offer.
The Bigger Picture: Retail Challenges
Both retailers are facing significant challenges in the current market. M&S is still recovering from a major cyber hack in 2025 that cost the company over £100 million. John Lewis is also struggling with higher costs and declining consumer confidence.
Despite these challenges, both brands are using their Christmas ads to connect with customers in new and innovative ways. M&S’s campaign reflects its successful turnaround, aligning its fashion and food offerings to appeal to younger consumers. John Lewis, meanwhile, is targeting affluent customers with a more traditional, luxurious approach.
Final Thoughts
This year’s Christmas ad battle is more than just a competition—it’s a reflection of changing consumer preferences and the evolving retail landscape. Whether you prefer the playful, modern approach of M&S or the elegant, traditional style of John Lewis, there’s something for everyone.
{{appel_action}}
Source : The Guardian - Business